SmallBizGenius Analysis

Musiciansfriend receives generally positive feedback, particularly for its helpful gear advisors and customer service. However, some customers report issues with receiving used or damaged items, and website functionality.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 276 recent reviews

Customer Service

9.0/10

Reviewers consistently praise the helpfulness and knowledge of Musiciansfriend's gear advisors. Many reviews specifically mention individual representatives by name, highlighting their personalized assistance, problem-solving skills, and friendly demeanor, such as Karl Simon, Ava Bollinger and Kelsey Tobin.

52 reviews mention this

Product Quality & Condition

4.0/10

A significant number of reviewers report receiving used, damaged, or incorrectly described items when purchasing new. Issues include scratches, missing parts, cigarette smoke odor, and guitars being dried out or having cracked necks.

21 reviews mention this

Shipping & Delivery

6.0/10

While some reviewers praise fast shipping, others report issues with damaged packaging, items not arriving on time despite paying for expedited shipping, and incorrect delivery information.

15 reviews mention this

Website Experience

5.5/10

Several reviewers mention difficulties with the Musiciansfriend website, including problems completing orders online, issues with PayPal integration, and malfunctioning tracking numbers.

8 reviews mention this

Returns & Issue Resolution

7.0/10

When issues arise, many reviewers report that Musiciansfriend is responsive in resolving the problem, offering replacements, refunds, or compensation for damages. However, the initial issues with product quality and shipping create the need for resolution in the first place.

10 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Helpful and knowledgeable gear advisors provide personalized assistance. Mentioned 52x
"Karl Simon was awesome. Very helpful and extremely responsive. He went above and beyond and I greatly appreciate it!"
Wide selection of musical instruments and equipment. Mentioned 8x
"Great selection and a well developed and easy to navigate web site and mobile app. The entire process is easy."
Company is responsive in resolving issues. Mentioned 10x
"Well I ordered a used item and it was boxed terribly and so of course when it shipped got destroyed. Some of the parts were missing for the amplifier but, the musician's Friend associate took care of it and sent me the parts that were no longer there that I need to use the amp so they made it right"
Offers financing options. Mentioned 2x
"Nic has been my MF agent for all my recent purchases. He’s gone beyond the normal call of duty to assist with information regarding items then helping me navigate Fortiva for making purchases."
Competitive pricing and deals. Mentioned 5x
"Great deal on the cool cajon !!! And to get it on sale, with a discount, free shipping AND Customer Appreciation Points ? I SAVED $50, at least !!!"

Common Complaints

Receiving used or damaged items when purchased as new. Mentioned 21x
"Musician's Friend AGAIN sent me a used item: the bases and one pole have deep paint scratches and scuff marks (the pole scratch was down to bare metal), and they reek of cigarette smoke!"
Issues with shipping and delivery, including damaged packaging and delays. Mentioned 15x
"I paid for 2 brand new powered speakers but the package came from a store instead of a warehouse. Also one of the package was damaged and the other unit came with the manufacturer package without a pa..."
Website usability issues, such as problems completing orders. Mentioned 8x
"Poorly functioning web page prevented me from placing the order on line. Tried twice, finally had to call it on…a very unsatisfactory buying experience."
Backorders and inaccurate stock information. Mentioned 3x
"Had previously ordered @ cases on the Stupid Deal of the day back on 10-25-25. Cases were on back order and still are."
Inconsistent packaging quality. Mentioned 3x
"Well I ordered a used item and it was boxed terribly and so of course when it shipped got destroyed."

Common Questions About Musiciansfriend

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Musiciansfriend legit and trustworthy?

Musiciansfriend is generally considered a legitimate retailer of musical instruments and equipment, with many customers reporting positive experiences. However, a notable number of reviewers have reported receiving used or damaged items when purchasing new, which raises concerns about quality control. While Musiciansfriend often resolves these issues through replacements or refunds, the inconsistency in product quality is a factor to consider. Overall, while most customers have positive experiences, it's wise to carefully inspect orders upon arrival.

Based on 45 reviews

Does Musiciansfriend have good customer service?

Musiciansfriend is frequently praised for its excellent customer service, particularly the helpfulness and knowledge of its gear advisors. Many reviewers specifically mention individual representatives by name, highlighting their personalized assistance and problem-solving skills. These advisors are often commended for going above and beyond to assist customers with their purchases and resolve any issues that arise. This strong focus on customer support is a significant strength of Musiciansfriend.

Based on 52 reviews

Is Musiciansfriend worth it for small business?

Musiciansfriend can be a worthwhile option for small businesses in the music industry, such as music schools or small venues, due to its wide selection, financing options, and helpful gear advisors. The ability to consult with knowledgeable representatives can be particularly beneficial when making purchasing decisions for equipment. However, small business owners should be aware of the reported issues with product quality and shipping, and carefully inspect all orders upon arrival to avoid potential disruptions.

Based on 6 reviews

What is Musiciansfriend's return policy like?

The reviews do not provide explicit details regarding Musiciansfriend's formal return policy. However, several reviewers mention receiving replacements or refunds when they received damaged or incorrect items, suggesting that the company is generally accommodating in resolving such issues. It is advisable to consult Musiciansfriend's website or contact their customer service directly for specific details regarding their return policy, including timeframes and conditions.

Based on 10 reviews

Why do some Musiciansfriend customers report receiving used items?

The reasons for customers receiving used items when purchasing new from Musiciansfriend are not explicitly stated in the reviews. However, possible explanations include errors in order fulfillment, misrepresentation of product condition, or issues with quality control in the warehouse or at Guitar Center locations used for sourcing. Regardless of the cause, this issue is a recurring theme in negative reviews and should be a concern for potential customers.

Based on 21 reviews

Ready to Try Musiciansfriend?

Save on your first purchase with 5 verified coupon codes.

View Coupons

Looking for Something Different?

Compare Musiciansfriend against 12 similar photography & media options.

View Alternatives